Birchbox Reviews

Birchbox has an overall rating of 4.3 based on 36 reviews. Customer feedback on Birchbox is mixed: Birchbox reviewers highlight positive aspects like variety of products, personalized selections, convenient subscription model, great for trying new brands, which strongly appeal to beauty enthusiasts, busy individuals, gift shoppers, those seeking new products. However, Birchbox is often criticized for its inconsistent product quality, high price for some items, shipping delays, limited full-size products.

4.3/5.0

36 reviews

5 Stars

19

4 Stars

7

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

2

1 Star

0

All Birchbox Reviews (36)
charlotte-Nadler
May 19, 2026
"Some of the boxes felt like they..."
Some of the boxes felt like they actually matched my profile well, which was nice. But then other times I’d get items that just weren’t my style at all and I knew I’d never use them. It’s not a bad service, I just wouldn’t say the personalization is super accurate every time.
james.Mize
May 15, 2026
"Super easy to pause when I needed to"
I liked how simple it was to pause or switch my plan whenever I needed. I even asked support just to make sure, and they basically said something like, “Yep, you can pause or change it anytime,” which was reassuring. No hassle at all
john.Dedeke
May 15, 2026
"The rewards actually keep me coming back"
I’ve been using Birchbox for a bit now, the rewards are a big part of why I stick with it.

The points add up quicker than I expected, especially when I leave reviews or buy something I was already planning to get. I’ve used them on full-size products a few times, and it definitely makes the price feel a lot easier to justify.

Not every sample is a perfect match for me, but the rewards make the whole thing feel worth it overall. I’m happy with it
DAVIS
May 12, 2026
"Decent site, just a little awkward to use"
birchbox.com was mostly fine to browse, and I was able to find what I was looking for eventually. Some pages seemed to load a bit slowly for me, and the account section felt kind of all over the place. I’m sure it could be smoother, but it’s not a bad site overall. Just took more clicking around than I expected.
AliciaReal
May 06, 2026
"Shipping was super quick"
I ordered from birchbox and didn’t think it would come that fast. Got the tracking email quick too, and the box showed up earlier then I expected. Everything was packed good and nothing was messed up. No real hassle, just easy order and fast delivery.
denny2004
May 02, 2026
"Worked out well for my sensitive skin"
My skin is sensitive, like it reacts to random stuff for no clear reason, so I was a little worried trying these. But most of the samples were gentle enough and didn’t mess with my skin. One face cream did make me a bit red, so I just stopped using that one. Other than that, it was easy to change my preferences and avoid stuff that didn’t work for me
GRAF
April 27, 2026
"Packaging was fine, but could’ve been better"
The box itself looked nice, so I’ll give them that. I’m not saying it was terrible or anything, but one of the items was kind of loose inside, which made me a little nervous. Nothing was broken, so it worked out, I just think some extra padding would’ve made it feel more secure. Overall not bad, I just expected a bit more.
AQUINO
April 07, 2026
"Tracking was spot on"
I was expecting the tracking to be off a bit. You know how it usually says one thing and then the package shows up whenever. But this time... nope. It was actually right. Checked it, it said out for delivery, and then it showed up just like it said. Simple, but I appreciated it.
hello_rebecca486
April 07, 2026
"Pretty sure it’s a good value with the full sizes"
I think the full-size items make this a solid deal. Maybe it depends on what you’re looking for, but for me, it felt worth it.
robert-Wester
April 07, 2026
"I’ve been enjoying this box because it’s..."
I’ve been enjoying this box because it’s a fun way to try different products without committing to full sizes. That said, a few of the samples are tiny, some are gone after one or two uses, which feels a little disappointing. I still look forward to getting it each month, but I do wish they’d include a couple bigger items to make it feel more worth it.
ollie1986
March 29, 2026
"Cracked bottle, surprisingly un-cracked customer service"
One of the products in my Birchbox showed up cracked and did a cute little leak all over the box, which was exactly the spa-like experience I was hoping for. I sent customer service a photo, and they actually got back to me quickly. They sent out a replacement without making me jump through a million hoops, which I appreciated. It took a few days to arrive, but overall they handled it well. I’m giving 4 stars because the whole thing was annoying at first, but they did fix it without drama.
ASHMEN
March 28, 2026
"Clear updates that almost won me over"
I’m usually loyal to the brand I’ve been ordering from for years, so I wasn’t sure if I’d really switch. But I have to admit, the updates here were great. I always knew when my box shipped or if anything changed, and the emails were simple without being confusing or overdone. It made the whole experience feel easy.
Diane_lovelady86
March 19, 2026
"Support wasn’t much help"
I reached out to customer service with what I thought was a simple question, but it took them a while to get back to me. When they finally did, the answer felt super generic, like it was just copied and pasted from a script. Didn’t really solve anything, so yeah.
Steve-jameson
March 18, 2026
"Always something new in the box"
I’ve been liking Birchbox because it’s not just one type of thing every time. You get a mix of skincare, hair products, and little makeup items, so it actually feels fun to open. It doesn’t seem repetitive, which I really appreciate. Anyway, that’s it...
Jay-colen
March 17, 2026
"Canceling was actually painless"
Just wanted to share in case anyone else is nervous about canceling Birchbox — it was way easier than I expected. I found the option right in my account, followed the steps, and it went through quickly. No phone calls, no weird runaround, nothing like that. If you’re planning to cancel, I’d just recommend checking your account settings first because that worked fine for me
CZAJKOWSKI
March 14, 2026
"Clear pricing before I checked out"
I appreciated that the plan cost was shown upfront before checkout. It was nice seeing the exact price clearly listed, even the little details, so there weren’t any weird surprises at the end.
tyesha_Walley79
March 05, 2026
"Got my Birchbox promo with the order. Took..."
Got my Birchbox promo with the order. Took a bit longer than expected, but everything showed up fine.
CatherineRener
March 02, 2026
"I’ve been really happy with Birchbox so..."
I’ve been really happy with Birchbox so far. The products in my box actually matched the things I said I liked, which doesn’t always happen with subscription boxes. I got a nice mix of skincare and hair products, plus a couple of brands I hadn’t tried before. Nothing felt random or like they were just tossing in leftover samples. It was fun to open, and I’ll use most of it. I’m definitely planning to keep getting these boxes.
hello_keith371
March 01, 2026
"Missing item got fixed, just took awhile"
My order showed up with one thing missing, which was annoying tbh. I emailed support and they did get back to me, but it took a few days of back and forth before anything really happened. They eventually sent out the replacement, so it got sorted in the end. Just wish it hadnt taken so long. Not awful, but not amazing either.
Kathy_dunford81
February 25, 2026
"Usually on point"
I’ve been using Birchbox for a while, and for the most part, the stuff they send matches what I actually care about. I’m picky about what I pay attention to, so I mostly notice the hair products and skincare that fit my profile, and a lot of those have been things I’d genuinely try. Not every sample is amazing, and I do wish some of them were a little bigger, but overall it’s felt useful and relevant.

View More Reviews

Birchbox Q&A

I really want to try birch box but is it worth it?? will it always stay $10 a month? where do i fill out my personal profile?

Sonia.Smith
December 07, 2019

“They already raised it, stopped points for reviews on your products you receive, and they are dollar sized products.. Their ads sucked me in, as they did alot of people who are now stuck. And customer service could be a little more professional and atleast act like they care about their customers.”

I really want to try birch box but is it worth it? will it always stay $10 a month? where do i fill out my personal profile?

NellieHarris
October 24, 2019

“They already raised it, stopped points for reviews on your products you receive, and they are dollar sized products. Their ads sucked me in, as they did alot of people who are now stuck. And customer service could be a little more professional and atleast act like they care about their customers.”

How do i cancel my subscription to birchbox? i had a one year subscription and sent email to birchbox canceling that subscription. no response. now in my 2nd year with birchbox, have again sent an email canceling and, again, no response. really annoying. thanks for your help. camille manning

How do i cancel my subscription to birchbox? i had a one year subscription and sent email to birchbox canceling that subscription. no response. now in my 2nd year with birchbox, have again sent an email canceling and, again, no response. really annoying. thanks for your help. camille manning

Where is my gift to my granddaughter that i odered on 12-22-16 with guaranteed delivery on 12/27. today is 01-06-2017 and no signs of answers from them when it will be delivered.

orangebird889
January 06, 2017

“Sadly, I've been looking at the reviews of all the big subscription boxes, hoping to find one that's worth the slightest amount of money. Looking at the reviews, it looks like the boxes usually don't come in! I hope this is a different situation, but from what I've seen, It's a rip-off. Even though I've seen comments saying they don't come in, I've seen ones that say if you look at the website, there's an email that sometimes works (Even though I've seen comments that say that it doesn't). Maybe you can try a different company, like ipsy (Even though you should probably read the reviews first before having the chance to get scammed). Hope this can help.”

View More Q&As

Have a question about Birchbox?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.